gptt916 February 2016

Find the second smallest number in a list using recursion

I know there has been a question asked on this topic, but none of the answers have helped me. I don't need help with implementing the code, I just need help sorting through the recursive process for this.

I was originally thinking recursively return a tuple each level and compare to find the second smallest value. But this doesn't work as I want my function to only return 1 value in the end- the 2nd smallest value.

How would I go about the recursive process for this problem? Thank you!

Edit: Sorry about not including enough details, so here goes.

Function should work as follows:

>>> sm([1,3,2,1,3,2])
>>> 2

Second edit: Sorry for the delay, I was busy until now, finally was able to sit down and put what I had in mind into code. It works as intended, but I honestly think this is a very shitty and inefficient way of doing recursion, as you can probably tell I am new to the concept.

To rephrase my original question using the pseudo code below: Is it possible to do what I did here, but without wrapping it in a second function? That is, is it possible to have a function that only recursively calls its self, and returns 1 number- the second smallest number?

def second_smallest(list):
    def sm(list):
        if base case(len of list == 2):
            return ordered list [2nd smallest, smallest]
            *recursive call here*
            compare list[0] with returned ordered list
            eg: [3, [5,2]]
            re-arrange, and return a new ordered list
    return sm(list)[0]


Prune February 2016

I can think of several ways. The slow one is to find the largest value of the given list, and then recur on the rest of the list. When the list length is 2, don't make the recursive call.

A faster one is to find the smallest element, recur on the remainder of the list, iterating only twice. Write a routine to find the nth smallest element this way, and then wrap it in a routine that calls it with n=2.

Is that enough of a start?

comingstorm February 2016

You can write your recursive function to take 3 arguments: the first and second smallest values you've encountered so far, and the rest of the list, which you haven't inspected.

Then, by comparing the first element of the list argument with the two smallest-so-far, you can choose which 2 of the 3 to pass as the arguments to the next recursion.

You need to wrap this recursive function in a presentation function, which sets up and calls the recursive one, while handling cases like lists that have less than 2 elements.

def recurse(min1, min2, list):
    if len(list)==0:
        return min2
    first, rest = list[0], list[1:]
    if first < min1:
        return recurse(first, min1, rest)
    if first < min2:
        return recurse(min1, first, rest)
    return recurse(min1, min2, rest)

def second_smallest(list):
    if len(list) < 2:
        raise ValueError("too few elements to find second_smallest")
    a, b, rest = list[0], list[1], list[2:]
    if b < a:
        return recurse(b, a, rest)
        return recurse(a, b, rest)

This kind of solution isn't particularly Pythonic -- it's more of a functional programming style.

Finally, you can pass the arguments on the front of the list, and combine the two functions to get the kind of solution you're looking for:

def second_smallest(list):
    if len(list) < 2:
        raise ValueError("too few elements to find second_smallest")
    a, b = list[0], list[1]
    a, b = min(a,b), max(a,b)
    if len(list) == 2:
        return b
    c, rest = list[2], list[3:]
    if c < a:
        return second_smallest([c,a]+rest)
    if c < b:
        return second_smallest([a,c]+rest)
    return second_smallest([a,b]+rest)

Note that this function does some redundant work, because it can't know if it's being called first, or if it's calling itself recursively. Also, + creates a new list, so this code

MSeifert February 2016

One possible way is to create a function taking 3 parameters: list, and optional smallest_value and second_smallest. In the function pop the first element compare it to the smallest and second smallest and change the values if necessary. Then call the function again with the new list, smallest and second_smallest. The recursion should terminate when the list is empty and return the second smallest.

There are some tricky states (when one/both of the values are not yet set). But I think that's implementation details and you can ask again if you have any problems coding it.

Gene February 2016

You can use classical divide and conquer. Let f(x) be a function that returns a tuple (a,b) containing the smallest and next smallest elements in list x.

The base cases are when x has 0 or 1 elements. Beyond the base case, split the list in 2, recur to find the least two elements of each half, then pick the least 2 of these 4 as the result:

def min2(x):
  if len(x) == 0: return sys.maxsize, sys.maxsize
  if len(x) == 1: return x[0], sys.maxsize
  m = int(len(x)/2)
  a1, b1 = min2(x[:m])
  a2, b2 = min2(x[m:])
  return (a1, min(b1, a2, b2)) if a1 < a2 else (a2, min(b2, a1, b1))

def secondSmallest(x)
  return min2(x)[1]

Here I'm using sys.maxsize as "infinity."

Reti43 February 2016

You can use a flag to keep track whether you're in the most outer level of the calls.

def second_smallest(numbers, top_level=True):
    # Do your stuff and call `second_smallest(numbers[1:], False)` for any recursions.
    # When it comes to returning a value from the function, use the following.

    if top_level:
        return result[0]   # what your function ultimately returns
    return result          # [second, first] since you're still in recursive calls

AlokThakur February 2016

What I understand from question :- 1. Solution should be recursive 2. No inner function kind of hack 3. It should return second smallest and accept list as parameter My Code to solve this -

from inspect import getouterframes, currentframe
def second_smallest(ls):
    level = len(getouterframes(currentframe(1)))

    if len(ls)<2:
        return None
    if len(ls) == 2:
                if level == 1:
                    return max(ls)
                    return min(ls), max(ls)
        m,n = second_smallest(ls[1:])
        if ls[0]<=m:
            n = m
            m = ls[0]
        elif ls[0] < n:
            n = ls[0]
        if level == 1:
            return n
        return m,n

Note - This code works if you run as python program file

dawg February 2016

You can do something along these lines:

def rmin(li, n=2):
    def _rmin(li):
        if len(li) == 1:
            return li[0]
            m = _rmin(li[1:])
            return m if m < li[0] else li[0]  

    for i in range(n):
        x=_rmin([e for e in set(li) if e not in a]) 
    return x

Post Status

Asked in February 2016
Viewed 2,259 times
Voted 7
Answered 7 times


Leave an answer